youarewrong : Someone commented this may be an error as they may have used a zip instead of pin. I left this up since I was corrected but they took screen shots and posted them in this thread.
@Jalil : I totally agree this is card user error. No one is gonna physically clone a card on site and attempt to use a PIN transaction at the same daggum store. That's dumb. You use CREDIT option.
To me, this is all tin foil nothing sauce.